Survey of Insecticide Efficacy on Three-Cornered Alfalfa Hopper
ID
ENTO-555NP
Introduction
Spissistilus fetinus (Say) (Hemiptera: Membracidae) is a pest of various legume crops, including peanuts, soybeans, and alfalfa (Beyer et al. 2017), as well as other cultivated plants, such as grapes (Flasco et al. 2021). Commonly known as the threecornered alfalfa hopper (TCAH), this pest ranges from the Midwest to the southeast U.S. (Beyer et al. 2017). TCAH are native to Virginia but have only become a problem in recent years (Musser et al. 2019 and 2020). TCAH are phloem feeders with piercing-sucking mouthparts and will typically girdle a plant’s stem (Mitchell & Newsom 1984), reducing the stem’s stability and increasing the plant’s risk of lodging (Sparks & Boethel 1987). In order to determine the best management strategies for TCAH, a summary of past insecticide efficacy trials was made.
Description
TCAH have a triangular or wedge-shaped pronotum as adults (Fig. 1). Nymphs develop through five instars (Wildermuth 1915), and early instars are light green or tan and are covered in dorsal spines (Fig. 2., Beyer et al. 2017). As they grow, TCAH become greener and begin to lose their spines. Nymphs and adults have piercing-sucking mouthparts and feed on the phloem of plants (Beyer et al. 2017).
Methods
A compilation of insecticide treatments on soybeans, alfalfa, or peanuts to determine their efficacy in reducing TCAH was created using data published in the journal Arthropod Management Tests. Only studies completed after 1980 were used. Studies with low TCAH pretreatment populations were omitted. Insecticides that are not registered in Virginia were also omitted. All treatments recorded were tested in the field. A summary was then written to determine the percentage of trials that were effective in controlling TCAH for each product.
Results
Overall, the top performing insecticides against TCAH were the pyrethroids Baythroid XL and Brigade, along with Sivanto, and the combo products Endigo ZC, and Leverage 360, which combined a neonicotinoid with a pyrethroid. Insecticides that also resulted in significant control in >50% of trials included Asana XL, Orthene, Mustang Max, Warrior/Karate, Prevathon, and Steward.
| Product | Active Ingredient (IRAC Group) | # trials | % trials reporting significant control |
|---|---|---|---|
| Baythroid XL | Beta- Cyfluthrin (3) | 6 | 100% |
| Brigade | bifenthrin (3A) | 1 | 100% |
| Sivanto | flupyradifuro ne (4D) | 1 | 100% |
| Endigo ZC | lambda- cyhalothrin (3A) + thiamethoxa m (4A) | 2 | 100% |
| Leverage 360 | imidacloprid (4A) + beta-cyfluthrin (3A) | 1 | 100% |
| Asana XL | esfenvalerate (3A) | 11 | 82% |
| Orthene | acephate (1B) | 16 | 81% |
| Mustang Maxx | zeta-cypermetherin (3A) | 8 | 75% |
| Warrior II/ Karate Z | lambda-cyhalothrin (3A) | 15 | 67% |
| Prevathon | chlorantranili prole (28) | 3 | 67% |
| Steward | indoxacarb (22A) | 2 | 50% |
| Dimethoate | dimethoate (1B) | 2 | 0% |
| Lannate | methomyl (1A) | 11 | 1% |
| Intrepid 2F | methoxyfeno zide (18) | 2 | 0% |
Source: Data obtained from Arthropod Management Tests focused on insecticide efficacy against the three-cornered alfalfa hopper.
References
Andrews, G.L., J. Goddard. 1986. “Control of Soybean Insects in South Mississippi.” Insecticide and Acaricide Tests 11: 339–340
Bacheler, J., D.D. Reisig, D.W. Mott, B. Peele. 2010. “Evaluation of Insecticide for Threecornered Alfalfa Hopper Control.” Arthropod Management Tests 35
Baur, M.E., T.S. Hall, B.J. Fitzpatrick, D.J. Boethel. 1998. “Evaluation of Insecticides for Threecornered Alfalfa Hopper Control on Soybean.” Arthropod Management Tests 24
Beyer, B.A., R. Srinivasan, P.M. Roberts, and M.R. Abney. 2017. “Biology and Management of the Threecornered Alfalfa Hopper (Hemiptera: Membracidae) in Alfalfa, Soybean, and Peanut.” Journal of Integrated Pest Management 8: 10
Cook, D.R. 2008. “Efficacy of Selected Insecticides Against Stink Bugs on Soybean.” Arthropod Management Tests 33
Crowe, B.D., R.M. McPherson, M.L. Wells. 2000. “Control of Stink Bugs, Velvetbean Caterpillars and Threecornered Alfalfa Hoppers on Georgia Soybeans.” Arthropod Management Tests 25
Davis, J.A., A.R. Richter, J.H. Temple, B.R. Leonard. 2009. “Efficacy of Foliar Insecticides for Control of Stink Bugs and Threecornered Alfalfa Hopper.” Arthropod Management Tests 34
Fitzpatrick, B.J., M.E. Baur, D.J. Boethel. 2000. “Evaluation of Insecticides Against Threecornered Alfalfa Hopper on Soybeans.” Arthropod Management Tests 26
Fitzpatrick, B.J., M.E. Baur, D.J. Boethel. 2002. “Evaluation of Insecticides Against the Threecornered Alfalfa Hopper and Southern Green Stink Bug.” Arthropod Management Tests 27
Fitzpatrick, B.J., M.M. Willrich, D.J. Boethel, and B.R. Leonard. 2000. “Evaluation of Insecticides Against Stink Bug and Threecornered Alfalfa Hopper on Soybean.” Arthropod Management Tests 26
Flasco, M., V. Hoyle, E. Cieniewicz, B. Roy, H. McLane, K.L. Perry, G.M. Loeb, B. Nault, M. Cilia, and M. Fuchs. 2021. “Grapevine Red Blotch Virus is Transmitted by the Three-Cornered Alfalfa Hopper in a Circulative, Nonpropagative Mode with Unique Attributes.” Phytopathology
Fontenot, K.A., J.H. Temple, B.R. Leonard, P.P. Price, J.T. Hardke. 2009. “Evaluation of Selected Insecticides to Manage Threecornered Alfalfa Hopper and Redbanded Stink Bug in Soybeans.” Arthropod Management Tests 34
Gable, R.H., B.R. Leonard, K. Tindall, J. Temple. 2004. “Evaluation of Insecticides Against Stink Bugs, Bean Leaf Beetles, and Threecornered Alfalfa Hoppers.” Arthropod Management Tests 29
Hall, T.S., J.H. Fife, M.E. Baur, D.J. Boethel, B.R. Leonard. 1999. “Threecornered Alfalfa Hopper Control on Soybean.” Arthropod Management Tests 24
Howard, J.E., D.S. Akin. 2012. “Evaluation of Labeled Foliar-Applied Insecticides Against Three Cornered Alfalfa Hopper in Soybean.” Arthropod Management Tests 37
Layton, B., J. Hamer, R. Smith. 1991. “Control of Soybean Insects in Mississippi.” Insecticide and Acaricide Tests 16
McPherson, R.M. 1990. “Soybean Insect Control in Georgia.” Insecticide and Acaricide Tests 15
McPherson, R.M., J.D. Taylor, N.J. Roberson. 2003. “Control of Velvetbean Caterpillars on Soybeans and Impact on Soybean Loopers and Threecornered Alfalfa Hoppers.” Arthropod Management Tests 28
McPherson, R.M., M.H. Bass.1993. “Control of Arthropod Pests on Georgia Soybean.” Insecticide and Acaricide Tests 18: 271
McPherson, R.M., W.A. Mills, III, S.R. Jones. 2005. “Control of Stink Bugs, Velvetbean Caterpillars, and Threeconered Alfalfa Hoppers on Soybeans in Georgia.” Arthropod Management Tests 30
Mitchell, P.L., and L.D. Newsom. 1984. “Histological and Behavioral Studies of Threecornered Alfalfa Hopper (Homoptera: Membracidae) Feeding on Soybean.” Annals of the Entomological Society of America 77
Muegge, M.A. 2011. “Effect of Selected Insecticides on Three Cornered Alfalfa Hopper and Beneficial Arthropods in Alfalfa.” Arthropod Management Test 36
Musser, F., A. Catchot, S. Conley, J. Davis, C. Difonzo, J. Greene, G. Lorenz, D. Owens, T. Reed, D. Reisig, P. Roberts, T. Royer, N. Seiter, S. Stewart, S. Taylor, K. Tilmon, R. Villanueva, and M. Way. 2019. “2018 Soybean insect losses in the United States.” Midsouth Entomologist 12: 1-24
Musser, F., A. Catchot, S. Conley, J. Davis, C. Difonzo, J. Greene, G. Lorenz, D. Owens, D. Reisig, P. Roberts, T. Royer, N. Seiter, R. Smith, S. Stewart, S. Taylor, K. Tilmon, R. Villanueva, and M. Way. 2020. “2019 Soybean Insect Losses in the United States.” Midsouth Entomologist 13. 1-23
Natwick, E.T., M.I. Lopez. 2011. “Efficacy of Insecticides for Leafhopper Control Alfalfa.” Arthropod Management Tests 36
Parker, J.L., J. Chapman, T.S. Williams, K. Emfinger, B.R. Leonard. 2012. “Evaluation of Selected Insecticides for Control of Soybean Looper and Threecornered Alfalfa Hopper.” Arthropod Management Tests 37
Price, P., J.H. Temple, K.D. Emfinger, B.R. Leonard. 2007. “Evaluation of Selected Insecticides for Control of Three-Cornered Alfalfa Hopper.” Arthropod Management Tests 33
Smith, J.F., A.L. Catchot. 2007. “Efficacy of Foliar Insecticides Against Southern Green Stink Bug, Three Cornered Alfalfa Hopper, Bean Leaf Beetle and Soybean Loopers in Soybean (Test 2).” Arthropod Management Tests 34
Smith, T.P., J.H. Temple, P. Price, B.R. Leonard. 2007. “Evaluation of Selected Insecticides for Control of Red Banded Stinkbugs and Threecornered Alfalfa Hoppers.” Arthropod Management Tests 32
Sparks, A.N., and D.J. Boethel. 1987. “Late-Season Damage to Soybeans by Three-Cornered Alfalfa Hopper (Homoptera: Membracidae) Adults and Nymphs.” Journal of Economic Entomology 80
Sutherland, D.B.S., M.R. Abney. 2017. “Evaluation of Foliar Insecticides for the Control of Threecornered Alfalfa Hopper and Garden Fleahopper in Peanut.” Arthropod Management Tests 43
Temple, J.H., K. Fontenot, J. Hardke, P. Price, B. R. Leonard. 2007. “Evaluation of Selected Insecticides for Control of Stink Bugs and Three-Cornered Alfalfa Hoppers.” Arthropod Management Tests 33
Torrance, T.N., M.R. Abney. 2020. “Efficacy of Select Insecticides Against Threecornered Alfalfa Hopper in Peanut.” Arthropod Management Tests 45
Way, M.O., R.A. Pearson, M.S. Nunez. 2010. “Evaluation of Selected Insecticides for Control of a Complex of Soybean Insects” Arthropod Management Tests 36
Way, M.O., R.G. Wallace. 1995. “Evaluation of Karate for Management of Arthropods in Soybean” Arthropod Management Tests 20: 246
Wier, A.T., J.D. Thomas, M.L. Boyd, D.J. Boethel., B.R. Leonard. 1993. “Control of Threecornered Alfalfa Hopper on Soybean.” Insecticide and Acaricide Tests 18
Wier, A.T., J.S. Mink, D.J. Boethel, B.R. Leonard. 1990. “Control of Bean Leaf Beetle, Banded Cucumber Beetle, and Threecornered Alfalfa Hopper on Soybean in Louisiana.” Insecticide and Acaricide Tests 16
Wier, T., D.J. Boethel, R.L. Hutchinson. 1990. “Control of Threecornered Alfalfa Hopper on Soybean with Foliar Insecticides.” Insecticide and Acaricide Tests 15
Wildermuth, V.L. 1915. “Three-Cornered Alfalfa Hopper.” Journal of Agricultural Research
Wolf, S.P., T.P. Mack. 1993. “Evaluation of Insecticides for Control of Soybean Loopers and Threecornered Alfalfa Hoppers on Soy-Beans.” Insecticide and Acaricide Tests 18
Wolf, S.P., Z. DeLamar, T.P. Mack. 1993. “Evaluation of Insecticides for Control of the Threecornered Alfalfa Hopper on Peanuts.” Insecticide and Acaricide Tests 18
Virginia Cooperative Extension materials are available for public use, reprint, or citation without further permission, provided the use includes credit to the author and to Virginia Cooperative Extension, Virginia Tech, and Virginia State University.
Virginia Cooperative Extension is a partnership of Virginia Tech, Virginia State University, the U.S. Department of Agriculture, and local governments. Its programs and employment are open to all, regardless of age, color, disability, sex (including pregnancy), gender, gender identity, gender expression, genetic information, ethnicity or national origin, political affiliation, race, religion, sexual orientation, or military status, or any other basis protected by law.
Publication Date
April 12, 2023
